Pages

Pecking proverbial milk tops from fine dining establishments across the UK

Friday, 5 November 2010

Yauatcha, London

15 Broadwick Street, Soho, W1F 0DL *
Open Monday to Saturday 12pm -11.45pm Sunday 12pm-10.30pm. No lunch menu. This meal £55 per head

7/10

I did not arrive at Yauatcha in the best of spirits. Rain, roadworks and a taxi journey from the innermost circle of hell meant that by the time I entered the chic Soho venue I was out of breath, wet and 20 minutes late to meet L. This was not a good start to a visit to a restaurant about which I was already apprehensive. On the one hand, I had heard nothing but good things about this Michelin starred Chinese restaurant. On the other, Yauatcha was started by a certain Alan Yau, at whose most famous creation, Hakkasan, I had a disastrous meal in Abu Dhabi only 3 months ago. Although both restaurants have left his empire, this common thread was unnerving.

When I sat down, two things immediately reassured me that tonight would be better than that spent in the gulf. First, L had ordered me a perfectly mixed Bombay Sapphire and tonic which was waiting at my seat when I arrived. Secondly, the restaurant itself looked breathtaking. The main dining room is underground. Dark, with carved black wood predominating and tasteful lighting throughout, the place is nothing if not achingly hip. The crowing glory, though, is surely the tropical fish tank-cum-bar which dominates the east side of the room. Tacky? Not here. It works.



The delay meant we were both hungry, and quickly ordered a good selection from the menu to share. First to arrive were the venison puffs; slow cooked juicy venison in flaky, crisp puff pastry. These were delieghtful morsels, intensely flavoursome, and enough on their own almost completely banish memories of Hakassan in the UAE (7/10).
Next to come were the dim sum proper. Scallop shui mai were tasty; the scallop cooked just right with a little hint of spice which did not overwhelm the it, all in and a perfectly steamed parcel which seemed to melt in the mouth (6/10). The char sui bun arrived next, which was almost identical to the ping-pong version of the same with which I have long had a love affair. Fluffy white exterior and incredibly intensely flavoured centre of hoi sin pork (6/10).



The char sui bun was followed by a prawn and beancurd cheung fun. This was not a dish which I had had before, nor one which I would have ordered but the attentive and helpful waiter recommended it as a personal favourite and we chose it accordingly. The cheung fun arrived in the form of a long rice noodle roll,sliced like a California sushi roll and covered in a sweet soy sauce. There was ample for two on the plate. The dish was simply exquisite. The prawn was succulent, meaty and full of flavour – comparable to lobster tail. The bean curd gave a satisfying crunchy texture which complimented the prawn beautifully, and both worked perfectly with the sweet sauce (8/10) So good was it, that we promptly ordered another.

Shortly after came an order of fried chili squid with wheat flake and curry leaf. This was another triumph for Yauatcha. The squid had been sliced and lightly scored before being deep fried. The spices were subtle, with the curry leaf detectable just and a very satisfying kick of chili heat. The golden fried wheat flakes were generously scattered over the whole dish (along with more chili flakes) adding a very pleasing crunchy texture, with both L and I picking at them with our fingers long after the squid had disappeared (7/10).

The final course to arrive (at the same time as the second portion of cheung fun) was a portion of crispy duck rolls. This was a very pleasant version of the best thing on any Chinese takeaway menu, served with a generous number of pancakes, crisp vegetables and a good hoi sin source that I was only slightly too full to enjoy properly (6/10).

If my trip to Yautscha found me arriving frustrated, it left me leaving happy. Not only is the price outstanding but here is a restaurant whose food is truly deserving of its Michelin star. Add in a pitch perfect décor and friendly, knowledgeable staff, and I can only say that the hype surrounding this restaurant is all that it deserves. Mr Yau, for Abu Dhabi, you are forgiven.

Sunday, 5 September 2010

Hakkasan, Abu Dhabi

Hakkasan Abu Dhabi, Emirates Palace, West Corniche Road P.O. Box 39999, Abu Dhabi, UAE

Open until late Sat- Thurs. No set lunch, cost per person 150UAED+


2/10

Robins don’t normally migrate, I understand, especially not in the middle of summer. But this week found me in the heat of Abu Dhabi, sitting in Hakkasan in the Emirates Palace with IM and B, B having recently taken up a job in the UAE.

I have never been to Hakkasan before. I know this is a mortal sin for a professed lover of food in an age when one cant get through a day at the office without someone mentioning that they or someone they know are meeting for dinner at the ubiquitous Fitzrovia restaurant. Alan Yau’s most famous creation as always appealed to me, however, and in the glamorous settings of the worlds most expensive hotel I was more excited than ever to sample its deleights.



The décor in the place seemed very similar to that in London (I’ve seen pictures) though according to the chain’s website, it has been given a ‘modern ethnic’ (presumably Arabic) interpretation. This wasn’t terribly in evidence, but the place is certainly chic, especially by Abu Dhabi standards: sumptuous cushions, carved dark wood all bathed in blue light. The wood panels, set in steel frames, section the restaurant off into small booths, which makes for an intimate atmosphere between groups of diners.
We sat down to eat and it was immediately apparent that something was very wrong with the service. A waiter with no Arabic and very poor English had obviously not been briefed on even the most rudimentary facets of the menu. Questions about the origin of the dishes, the size of the portions and the different accompaniments available on Hakkasan’s extensive and non too simple menu went unanswered. Instead, we were pushed a dish of the day, in which no one had expressed an interest.

When we had chosen our dishes, the waiter came only to explain that a number of the items we has selected were unavailable. I still do not know how the crispy shredded veal rib eye or the Jasmine tea smoked Wagyu beef ribs taste, nor has B had the stir-fry lobster in black bean sauce with lotus root. The waiter did not know what the cause of the supply problems was (of course) and did not seem to appreciate that it would have been nice to know at the outset which dishes were unavailable.



This disappointment we ordered again off a now slimmed down menu. The food arrived pleasingly quickly and looked admittedly, wonderful. Obviously someone at the hotplate was exercising firm quality control over what went out, which bode well for the taste. I had plumped for the stir fry chicken with red chili, accompanied by edamame egg fried rice. The rice was perfectly cooked, not oily or greasy at all (7/10). The chicken was something else though. To be sure, I had ordered chili chicken, but in what arrived there was almost one whole dried red chili for every piece of shredded chicken. The result was blisteringly hot, and added only the musty, slightly bitter taste of dried chilies to the dish. Needless to say, the meal ended with a pile of dried chili on my plate after I decided it really was worth the trouble of picking it out. The chicken was perfectly satisfactory, but no better than I believe I create in my wok at home (2/10).

B had opted for scallops with ginger, chili and pak choi, a dish which he was assured did not require rice or any other accompaniment. What arrived looked beautiful, but only contained 3 scallops, in a little tower with – yes – the all pervasive whole dried red chilies. The scallops were perfectly cooked, but, one chili later, and all taste was obliterated. Further, by the end of this ‘meal’, B was reaching over to my rice (by now fast emerging the star of the meal) to fill up on (3/10).

IM’s main dish arrived a little after ours. He had ordered the famous Hakka steamed dim sum platter. Again this arrived looking beautiful, with the little multi-coloured steamed parcels sitting in their bamboo container. The result was again, disappointing. The dim sum were majorly overcooked and stuck to the bottom of the container like glue. Chopsticks weren’t up to the job of removing them and soon we were all diving with our hands to taste. The skin of the dim sum was thick, very chewy and slightly slimy in texture. A scallop dim sum was delicious, but a second, while looking deliciously enticing, tasted of nothing but very spicy chili. (2/10)

None of our party opted for a desert, opting instead for coffee, which came quickly and was perfectly adequate (5/10).

That Hakkasan was such a disappointment is in some ways a compliment to the brand. Even on another continent, my expectations dining in a Hakkasan restaurant were raised sky high. Of course, the crashing disappointment that the reality brought is indicative of the other face of global expansion – once you go global, you lose control. The CEO had clearly lost control (or else his mind) here. Of course some of the problems were particular to the location – I’m sure that half of the menu in London isn’t struck out each night as deliveries fail to fly in, and I’m sure that the waiting staff are not as incompetent as in the Emirates, whose national brand is hardly synonymous with excellent service. But nevertheless, the dishes which I sampled in the Emirates Palace also feature on the menu in the Michelin star holding Fitzrovia restaurant, and perhaps that’s the reason I’m still yet to visit.

A final thought for those of you it couldn’t happen here. Remember this: the Hakkasan brand has been sold…to an Abu Dhabi corporation.

What did other people think? Hakkasan on Urbanspoon

Saturday, 29 August 2009

Martin Wishart, Edinburgh

54 The Shore, Leith, Edinburgh, EH6 6RA

Open for Lunch Tues-Sat 12-2pm. Three Course: £24.50.

5/10

Today we made a visit to one of the four Michelin Starred restaurants in the city of Edinburgh. Three of these, including Martin Wishart’s which was to be our destination, are based in the suburb of Leith. A deliberate attempt had been made to introduce local diners to the practices of haute cuisine dining, with, for example, the waiters explaining the concept of a tasting menu. The atmosphere was very relaxed. While this was an efficiently-run ship, the atmosphere of the restaurant was friendly and welcoming. The décor of the restaurant was clear and light. The food experience here, overall, was very good without reaching excellent. This was a good, solid haute cuisine meal with one or two highlights which were above the standard of the rest of the fare.


Bread arrived in the form of four individual bread rolls, two white and two brown, baked in the shape of a muffin. These were freshly baked on the premises and arrived comfortingly warm. The bread was golden on the outside, with good light texture on the inside. I have to admit I prefer bread to be something more than plain white or brown, but these were good (5/10). An assiette of amuse bouches arrived soon after. The first was a delightfully fresh, both in taste and its vivid light green colour, courgette and pesto soup. At the bottom was a small amount of tomato chutney, which perhaps could have done with having a more vinegary bite (7/10). Next was deep fried polenta with shrimp. This was so-so as the shrimp did not succeed in intruding on the dominant carbohydrate-y flavour of the polenta. There was even a slight hint of greasiness (3/10). Finally, a few slices of beetroot in a blood pudding sauce topped with crispy rice. This was an interesting combination of the grainy and thick sauce, the chunky beetroot and the crunch of the rice. This was K’s first experience of blood pudding, and I would have thought she would have enjoyed the similarities of the sauce with dark chocolate. In all, this was interesting more than tasty (5/10).


K’s starter was the highlight of the meal. Smoked organic Shetland salmon with a layer of pickled cucumber on the top and a foam of konbu vinegar. The salmon was gorgeous: succulent, smooth, intense salmon flavour without ever being ‘fishy’. The cucumber and vinegar added a counterpoising punch but K, desiring to enjoy the salmon in its full glory on its own, ate this separately (8/10). My duck rillettes – potted duck belly – came with a salad made up of beetroot, pickled cabbage, salad leaves and shredded carrot and with a rather pointless thin slice of toasted Polaine bread which was too thin to register any actual flavour. This was a disappointment compared to the salmon. Rillettes is perhaps not the most aesetheticaly pleasing of meat; in this case having a drab grey colour which I associate with mass produced cheap factory chicken. The acidity of the pickled cabbage added a nice contrast to the duck; the meat itself was enjoyable without being amazing (4/10)


My main course consisted of two fillets of poached sole, each wrapped around a boiled potato surrounded by a mushroom gratin and steamed spinach. The fish was succulent but, equally, rather flavourless. The softness of the fish was contrasted nicely by the al dente nature of the potatoes. The mushroom gratin was a little lifeless and, presented as a sauce around the fish and left on an extremely hot plate, had begun to develop a skin by the time it arrived at the table (4/10). K had a roast saddle of Dornoch lamb with creamed runner beans, mashed potatoes, chunks of tomato, a lattice of potato and thyme jus. Similar to the sole, the lamb was a very well cooked piece of meat but also one lacking in any strong flavour. The mashed potatoes had a wonderful earthly flavour and colour (4/10).


K’s dessert was a beautifully crafted raspberry soufflé, companioned with a raspberry granite with a raspberry sorbet foam. The soufflé was a little light on the flavour side while the raspberry foam was wonderfully intense and had a very interesting texture – half-way between a sorbet and a foam (5/10). My dessert was somewhat bizarre. A lemon tart with fromage frais foam and yuzu sorbet, but this was placed in a pool of yuzu (Japanese citron) water. As you might expect, this watery foundation led to the base of the tart itself becoming rather soggy. The tart itself was very good, though it could have done with a little more filling. The sorbet was wonderfully light (5/10).

The petit fours we finished with were great; nought, coconut and line meringues and bons bons – gleddfiddich and chocolate, raspberry and passionfruit. The nougat was soft, almost like a marshmallow, and chewy. The meringue was light on lime flavour. The bon bons were the highlight and were uniformly good. The glenfiddich was essentially a very rich chocolate truffle with a whisky kick. Both the raspberry and passionfruit bon bons were powerful in their flavours.

What did other people think?

Martin Wishart on Urbanspoon